Top Mistakes Homeowners Make When Selecting a Replacement Door

January 27, 2025
A close up of a pink ribbon on a white background.
A hallway with a yellow door and stairs leading up to it.

What can go wrong with selecting a replacement door?

Many savvy homeowners become better informed when making large purchases for their homes – thanks to the wealth of knowledge on the Internet. However, we see many homeowners in Connecticut make the same mistakes when purchasing a replacement door. 


Don’t Make These 4 Mistakes When Selecting a Replacement Door

There are three steps in the process of purchasing new replacement doors. First, you must choose the door that tickles your fancy; second, you must purchase the door; third, the door must be installed. Following are some of the more common mistakes we have helped homeowners resolve.


1) Selecting a High Maintenance Material

These days, most people barely have time to relax or do hobbies, so the last thing you want to do is add door maintenance to your never-ending “to-do” list. For instance, many homeowners select wooden entry doors because, well, they are beautiful; however, they are likely unaware of just how much maintenance these doors require. Owners must sand, stain, and paint to protect the door from the elements.

Newer materials, such as fiberglass, can imitate wood’s appearance (if that’s what you want) very well and are virtually maintenance-free. Contact us to see samples of some pretty amazing replacement doors.


2) Buying Only Because It’s Cheap

Even if you have a tight budget we don’t recommend installing a cheap entry door, you’ll end up regretting wasting that money. Save your low-end options for another home improvement project, on one that isn’t quite so visible.


Your home’s replacement entry door is a highly visible feature and will likely be seen either by you or a passerby every single day. A cheap door will also not have the energy efficient benefits and could prove drafty. And a cheap door will probably require high maintenance. Choosing based on price alone rarely works out for Connecticut homeowners.


3) Assuming You Can Install it Yourself

You should turn to a professional door installer for the installation. Trust us, this task is not as easy as you may assume, and an incorrect installation can lead to a number of problems that you don’t want or need. An improperly installed door can:

  • Create Drafts – Negatively impact the energy efficiency of your home, let the cold in and let the heat out.
  • Be Hard To Use – The door can be difficult to open and close.
  • Security Risk – A poor installation can make your home less secure.


4) Deviating From the Home’s Architectural Style

Most homes have a prominent architectural style. You may be tempted to be adventurous with your new replacement door, but make sure you don’t overdo it. If you end up choosing an entry door that features an extremely bold color or design, you can make your house look very uncoordinated, leading to a decrease in curb appeal.


Replacement entry doors add value to your home by boosting curb appeal and improving overall energy efficiency. For the Connecticut climate, we recommend Therma-Tru entry doors. Consider the location of your door when you pick the finish, color, and material. If possible, set aside time to discuss these considerations with a ct door contractor.


Our Replacement Door experts at J.C. Tonnotti can provide advice that will help you make and install the door that is right for you.

Share this post

OTHER BLOG POSTS
White two-story suburban house with black shutters, a front lawn, and a driveway in autumn sunlight
October 28, 2026
Are Harvey windows worth it? A Connecticut installer reviews the Slimline, Classic, Tribute, and Majesty lines, glass options, warranty, and pros and cons.
Renovated living room with paint supplies on a drop cloth and furniture covered for painting
October 5, 2026
How much does interior painting cost in Connecticut? A local contractor breaks down room and square foot prices, prep, older homes, and what drives quotes.
Suburban house with beige siding and dormer windows beside a red and orange autumn tree
September 18, 2026
Why is fall the best time for a roof inspection in Connecticut? A GAF-certified local roofer covers the timing, what gets checked, and how to beat winter.
Beige house exterior with boarded-up windows and a closed boarded door
September 18, 2026
Fiber cement vs. vinyl siding for Connecticut homes: compare cost, durability, maintenance, and looks to choose the right one. Free estimates from CT pros.
September 9, 2026
Connecticut homeowners may qualify for a $100 rebate per window when installing eligible ENERGY STAR triple-pane windows. See who qualifies and how to apply.
Front porch with bright red door, gray siding, and trimmed shrubs in front of a house
August 19, 2026
How to choose a front entry door: compare steel, fiberglass, and wood on security, energy efficiency, style, and cost, with expert CT advice from the pros.